Spring Training Statistics

The big question is do Spring training statistics actually mean anything?

As players like Brett Lawrie and Eric Thames are making cases for their inclusion on the 25 man opening day Blue Jays roster, many people like myself caution against reading too much into spring training stats.  As a supporting argument there are often quick references to former Jays who had big springs and never translated their success into the major leagues, guys like Simon Pond who hit .343 one spring or Buck Coats who hit .409 and actually made the team. 

However does this mean we should dismiss all spring training successes or failures?  What about Jose Bautista last spring who put up an .895 SLG in the spring and then went on to surprise everyone in baseball by hitting 54 home runs?  At what point should we start paying attention to spring training statistics or when do they actually mean anything?

I don't really have the answers to these questions, but for fun I thought I would look at the total Blue Jays spring training statistics since 2002 for players with more than 20 AB's and see if there is anything that jumps out for spring training numbers.

Here are the Top 10 Blue Jays with the most Spring Training At Bats:

Player		Avg	G	AB	R	H	TB	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SLG
V	Wells	.290	146	445	66	129	203	26	3	14	76	.456
E	Hinske	.255	106	298	48	76	147	15	1	18	53	.493
A	Rios	.275	93	258	43	71	123	18	2	10	36	.477
A	Hill	.344	103	253	46	87	144	22	1	11	41	.569
R	Johnson	.295	90	244	27	72	96	15	0	3	25	.393
L	Overbay	.242	80	219	28	53	78	19	0	2	28	.356
R	Adams	.271	95	210	29	57	81	7	4	3	21	.386
J	McDonald	.249	92	209	20	52	64	6	0	2	16	.306
A	Lind	.265	70	181	19	48	80	16	5	2	22	.442
O	Hudson	.274	63	175	31	48	76	9	2	5	17	.434

Here are the Top 10 Blue Jays with the highest Spring Training SLG:

Player		Avg	G	AB	R	H	TB	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SLG
C	Koskie	.292	10	24	5	7	19	3	0	3	7	.792
S	Rolen	.387	29	62	14	24	48	6	3	4	9	.774
J	Lane	.364	22	55	9	20	40	5	0	5	13	.727
J	Bautista	.402	42	112	23	45	76	14	1	5	15	.679
J	Sequea	.429	13	21	2	9	14	0	1	1	5	.667
F	Menechino	.421	17	38	9	16	25	3	0	2	7	.658
J	Smith	.324	17	34	4	11	22	3	1	2	5	.647
G	Gross	.297	55	101	23	30	63	4	1	9	22	.624
S	Stewart	.388	46	134	29	52	81	19	2	2	19	.604
B	Emaus	.348	41	89	17	31	53	8	1	4	22	.596

Well if that isn't the who's who of the all time great Blue Jays, I'm not sure what is.

Here are the Top 10 Blue Jays with the lowest Spring Training SLG:

Player		Avg	G	AB	R	H	TB	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SLG
R	Olmedo	.000	14	21	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	.000
R	Diaz	.125	16	24	3	3	3	0	0	0	1	.125
A	Loewen	.136	19	22	2	3	3	0	0	0	1	.136
S	Fasano	.100	21	30	3	3	5	2	0	0	0	.167
R	Clayton	.154	15	39	4	6	7	1	0	0	5	.179
M	Vento	.143	14	21	4	3	4	1	0	0	1	.190
J	Matos	.200	17	25	1	5	5	0	0	0	2	.200
B	Jeroloman	.176	27	34	5	6	7	1	0	0	3	.206
M	Bordick	.184	18	38	2	7	9	2	0	0	1	.237
R	Ryan	.178	19	45	5	8	11	3	0	0	2	.244

This may suggest that if you have a terrible spring a major league career may not be your thing.

Without doing any in-depth analysis, mostly due to a lack of time, this exercise really hasn't changed my mind about the meaning of spring training statistics.  However if someone would like to look a little further into it, send me an email and I'll pass along my spread sheet of spring training stats for your enjoyment.